A Vision of Hope Media. Everyone has something to recover from. Books, curriculum, recovery, reentry, media.

Recovery & Reentry

Setting Boundaries With a Loved One in Recovery Without Cutting Them Off

A boundary is a rule about what you will do, not a rule about what the other person has to do. Families who hold boundaries and stay in contact give their person more to come back to than families who either give in or cut them off.

At a wooden kitchen table, an older woman hands a plain blue transit card to her adult son in a grey hoodie while her other hand rests on her closed brown wallet beside a coffee mug.
Table of contents

A lot of families feel like they only have two choices. They can keep helping. Sometimes that means paying for things that end up feeding the addiction. Or they can cut the person off and wait for them to hit bottom. Both choices usually come from fear. Both can leave the family worn out.

There is a third option, and most of the research on families and addiction points toward it. You can set clear limits on what you will and will not do, and still stay in the person’s life.

I am a formerly incarcerated person in recovery. I wrote in my memoir that if I had not had a supportive family when I was released, I would have been completely overwhelmed.[1] I also lied to that same family more than once while I was using. So I’m writing this for the people on the other side of that.

This is not medical or legal advice. It is a plain walk-through of what federal health agencies and family research say, with links to the sources.

Direct Answer

To set boundaries with a loved one in recovery without cutting them off, decide what you will and will not do, say it once in a calm moment, and then follow through with your own actions. Keep the contact you can safely keep. Reward the times they are sober instead of only reacting to the times they use. Take part in their treatment when you are invited. Treat a setback as a reason to adjust the plan, not a reason to end the relationship. Family approaches like CRAFT were built for exactly this, and in one randomized trial CRAFT got 64% of unwilling drinkers into treatment, compared with 13% for Al-Anon facilitation and 30% for a confrontational intervention.[2]

What is a boundary, and what is not?

A boundary is a rule about your own behavior. “I won’t give you cash.” “I won’t let anyone use in this house.” “If you call me high, I’ll tell you I love you and hang up, and we can talk tomorrow.” Each of those is something you control.

A demand is a rule about the other person’s behavior. “You have to stay sober.” “You have to go to meetings.” You can ask for those things, and it is fair to want them. You cannot make them happen. When families mix the two up, they end up making threats they cannot enforce. The person learns the threats do not mean much.

Cutting someone off is different again.

It ends contact. Sometimes that is necessary. If there is violence or your children are at risk, safety comes first; no article should talk you out of that. But for a lot of families the choice is not between giving in and walking away. It is about deciding which kinds of help you will keep giving and which ones you will stop.

How do you set a boundary that holds?

Where do you start? Start small and specific. “No using in the house” is clearer than “you need to respect us.” “I’ll drive you to work, but I won’t lend you the car” is clearer than “I’m done enabling you.”

Say it once, when the person is sober and things are calm. You do not need to argue it. You do not need to win the conversation. You are telling them what you are going to do so it is not a surprise later.

Then follow through.

This is the hard part. If you said you would not pay a bill and you pay it anyway, the person learns the boundary was a mood, not a decision. If you follow through without yelling or lecturing, they learn it was real.

When I was using, my mom let me drive her car while mine needed work, and my dad tried to fix mine while I was out the door getting or getting rid of drugs.[1] They were trying to help.

Looking back, though, that kind of help made it easier for me to keep going the way I was going.

So what makes a boundary hold? It usually comes down to a few plain things: it is about something you control (money, your home, your car, or your time), it is one or two things instead of ten, and everyone in the house agrees to it, so the person cannot go around it by asking someone else.

What is CRAFT, and why do families use it?

CRAFT stands for Community Reinforcement and Family Training. It was built for family members whose person refuses treatment. The family member goes to counseling, even if their loved one will not. They learn to notice when the person is sober and make that time more rewarding, to stop shielding them from the natural results of using, to communicate without attacking, to look after their own safety, and to watch for the moment the person might say yes to help.[3]

The best-known trial is Miller, Meyers, and Tonigan in 1999. It randomly assigned 130 family members of problem drinkers to one of three approaches, each with 12 hours of counseling. CRAFT got 64% of the drinkers into treatment. Al-Anon facilitation got 13%. The Johnson Institute intervention, which prepares the family for a surprise confrontation, got 30%. Most families who trained for the confrontation (70%) decided not to go through with it.[2] A parallel study with people using other drugs found CRAFT families got 74% of their loved ones into treatment.[3]

Two other findings from that trial are easy to miss. First, all three approaches helped the family members themselves feel better and get along better with their person. Second, engagement usually came after 4 to 6 sessions; this is not a one-conversation fix.[2]

CRAFT is one approach. SAMHSA’s guide for providers, TIP 39, describes several family-centered approaches and says treatment works better when programs build a family-centered culture instead of treating the family as an afterthought.[4] If CRAFT is not available near you, a family therapist or a program that offers family sessions can do much of the same work.

How can families take part in treatment?

A lot of programs invite families in. Families do not always know what that looks like. Depending on the program, it can mean any of these: family therapy sessions, a family education night, visiting days in residential treatment, or being part of discharge planning.

NIDA’s principles of addiction treatment say effective treatment has to deal with more than the drug use. It has to address medical, psychological, social, vocational, and legal problems too, and behavioral therapies include family counseling.[5] Families often know about those problems before anyone else does.

Here is what taking part usually involves:

What you can do Why it helps
Ask the program what family sessions it offers Many programs offer more than families ask for. TIP 39 lists family education, family therapy, and support groups.[4]
Go to family sessions even when they are hard You hear the treatment plan directly instead of secondhand.
Get your own support, like Al-Anon, Nar-Anon, SMART Family and Friends, or a counselor In the CRAFT trial, family members improved in every group, including Al-Anon.[2]
Help with the parts of the plan you can actually help with, like rides, a quiet place to study, or a phone call before a hard day It keeps your help tied to recovery instead of to the addiction.
Respect privacy rules Programs need written consent from the patient to share details with you.

If your person doesn’t want you involved, that is their right as an adult. You can still go to your own counseling and your own support group. That part does not need their permission.

What do you do after a setback?

NIDA compares relapse rates for substance use disorders, about 40% to 60%, with rates for other chronic illnesses like high blood pressure and asthma, which run about 50% to 70%. Its point is that a relapse does not mean treatment failed. It means treatment needs to be started again, changed, or replaced.[6]

Does that make a setback less painful? No.

It does change what families do next. Check for safety first: if opioids are involved, keep naloxone in the house and know how to use it. Keep the boundaries you already set, because a relapse is not the moment to drop them, and it is not the moment to add ten new ones.

Talk about the next step, not the whole history. “Do you want to call the program today?” is more useful than going over every broken promise. If they want to talk about what led up to it, listen for the specifics (stress, a new job, an old friend, a hard date on the calendar).

I have a whole page on what to say to a loved one after a relapse if you want the words.

What changes when they come home from jail or prison?

What changes is how much lands on the family at once.

A return from custody can bring supervision rules, a job search, no money, and no license in the same week. When I was released after 11 months, I came out with no job and no money.[1]

The research on family contact during incarceration is encouraging. A Minnesota Department of Corrections study of 16,420 people released between 2003 and 2007 found that people who got at least one visit in prison had a 13% lower risk of a new felony conviction and a 25% lower risk of being revoked for a technical violation. More visits, and more different visitors, were tied to lower risk.[7]

The weeks right after release also carry a real health risk (and families are often the first people there). A study in the New England Journal of Medicine found that in the first two weeks after release from Washington state prisons, the risk of death was 12.7 times higher than for other residents, and overdose was the leading cause.[8] That is one reason to have naloxone in the house before the person comes home.

Boundaries still apply here, and they may matter even more. If the person is on supervision, house rules about drugs and alcohol protect them as well as you. Be clear about what you can offer: a room for 60 days, rides to appointments, or help with a phone. Be clear about what you cannot. I wrote more about this in the family reentry guide.

How do you stay in their life without enabling?

Most families worry about enabling, and the word gets used so much that it can start to mean any kind of help at all.

A simpler test is to ask what the help makes easier. Does it make recovery easier, or does it make using easier?

Here is how that test plays out:

  • A ride to an outpatient group makes recovery easier.
  • Cash with no questions can make using easier.
  • The couch on the night they get out of detox can make recovery easier.
  • Covering for them when they miss work can make using easier.

You can keep calling. You can keep inviting them to dinner on the condition that they come sober. You can tell them you love them and that the rules are the same. CRAFT is built on this. It teaches families to make sober time worth more than using time.[3]

That is why cutting someone off so often works against what the family wants. The sober time can only be better if the family is still there for it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an example of a healthy boundary with someone in recovery?

A healthy boundary is about what you will do, not what they must do. For example, “I won’t give you cash, but I’ll pay for the bus pass directly,” or “No one uses in this house.” You say it once, calmly, and then follow through.

Is cutting someone off the same as setting a boundary?

No. A boundary limits what you will do. Cutting someone off ends contact. Ending contact may be necessary when there is violence or danger, but for most families a few clear limits work better than walking away. In the CRAFT trial, families who learned skills to use at home got more of their loved ones into treatment.[2]

What is CRAFT in addiction recovery?

CRAFT stands for Community Reinforcement and Family Training. It teaches family members to reward sober behavior, stop shielding the person from the results of using, communicate without attacking, and look after their own safety. In a 1999 randomized trial it got 64% of unwilling drinkers into treatment.[2][3]

How can families participate in addiction treatment?

Ask the program about family therapy, family education, visiting days, and discharge planning. SAMHSA’s TIP 39 describes these family-centered services for providers.[4] Families can also get their own support through Al-Anon, Nar-Anon, SMART Family and Friends, or a counselor.

Does a relapse mean treatment failed?

No. NIDA says relapse rates for substance use disorders, about 40% to 60%, are similar to rates for other chronic illnesses, and a relapse means treatment should be resumed, changed, or replaced.[6]

Does family contact help people coming home from prison?

Yes. A Minnesota Department of Corrections study of 16,420 releases found that any prison visit was tied to a 13% lower risk of a new felony conviction and a 25% lower risk of revocation for a technical violation.[7]

If you work with families

If you run a recovery or reentry program and want to talk through how family sessions could fit into your groups, you can book a call.

References

  1. Drasen A. A Vision of Hope. Memoir. Release with no job, no money, and no resources after 11 months, and “If I didn’t have a supportive family or had children, I would have been completely overwhelmed”; mom lending her car and dad working on mine while I was using.
  2. Miller WR, Meyers RJ, Tonigan JS. Engaging the unmotivated in treatment for alcohol problems: a comparison of three strategies for intervention through family members. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 1999;67(5):688-697. 130 family members; 12 hours of counseling; CRAFT 64%, Al-Anon facilitation 13%, Johnson Institute 30%; 70% did not go through with the confrontation; all groups improved family functioning; engagement after 4 to 6 sessions.
  3. Miller WR, Meyers RJ, Hiller-Sturmhöfel S. The Community-Reinforcement Approach. Alcohol Research & Health. 1999;23(2):116-121. CRAFT described as a family approach for loved ones who refuse treatment; parallel NIDA study engaged 74% of drug users.
  4. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. TIP 39: Substance Use Disorder Treatment and Family Therapy. Publication PEP20-02-02-012. Updated September 2020.
  5. National Institute on Drug Abuse. Principles of Drug Addiction Treatment: A Research-Based Guide (Third Edition). Effective treatment addresses medical, psychological, social, vocational, and legal problems; behavioral therapies include family counseling.
  6. National Institute on Drug Abuse. Treatment and Recovery. Drugs, Brains, and Behavior: The Science of Addiction. Relapse rates of 40% to 60% for substance use disorders compared with hypertension and asthma; relapse signals resumed, modified, or new treatment.
  7. Minnesota Department of Corrections. The Effects of Prison Visitation on Offender Recidivism. November 2011. 16,420 releases, 2003 to 2007; any visit tied to 13% lower felony reconviction risk and 25% lower technical violation revocation risk.
  8. Binswanger IA, Stern MF, Deyo RA, et al. Release from prison: a high risk of death for former inmates. New England Journal of Medicine. 2007;356(2):157-165. Risk of death in the first two weeks after release 12.7 times that of other residents; overdose the leading cause.