Table of contents
People who are ready to try a recovery group usually run into the same question. Which one? Somebody tells them to go to AA. Somebody else says AA did not work for them and SMART did. A third person has never heard of either. So the person does not go to anything.
This page is a plain side-by-side of the best-known free peer groups in the United States. It is not medical advice and it does not replace treatment. These groups are run by peers, not doctors, and many people use them alongside treatment.
Direct Answer
AA and NA follow the 12 Steps, with sponsors and a spiritual focus. SMART Recovery uses practical tools from behavioral therapy and has no steps or sponsors. LifeRing and Women for Sobriety are other non-12-step options. A 2018 study found similar results across these groups. The best one is the one you will keep attending.
What are the main recovery groups?
These are the groups most people will run into. All of them hold free peer meetings, in person and online.
| Group | Approach | Who it is for |
|---|---|---|
| Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) | 12 Steps, sponsors, a “higher power” of your own understanding | Anyone with a desire to stop drinking[1] |
| Narcotics Anonymous (NA) | 12 Steps adapted for any drug, sponsors | Anyone who wants to stop using drugs[2] |
| SMART Recovery | Four-point program based on CBT and REBT | People with any substance or behavior problem[3] |
| LifeRing Secular Recovery | Sobriety, secularity, self-help; each person builds their own plan | People who want an abstinence-based group without religion[4] |
| Women for Sobriety (WFS) | 13 Acceptance Statements in a “New Life” program | Women[5] |
There are other groups too, including faith-based and identity-based ones. This page sticks to AA, NA, and the three largest known secular groups in the United States. Those secular groups and 12-step groups are the ones a 2018 study compared side by side.[8]
How does AA work, and how is NA different?
AA is the oldest and largest of these groups. AA estimated 2,138,201 members in 129,790 groups worldwide in 2020, and it says those numbers come from group reports, not a formal count.[6] The only requirement to join is a desire to stop drinking, and there are no dues or fees.[1]
Meetings usually involve people sharing their own experience. Members work through the 12 Steps, often with a sponsor, who is a more experienced member who helps one-on-one. The Steps talk about a higher power. AA leaves it to each member to decide what that means.[1]
NA uses the same basic structure, but it is about drugs in general, not just alcohol.[2] Many towns have both, and some people go to both.
How does SMART Recovery work?
SMART stands for Self-Management and Recovery Training. It started in 1994 and is based on two kinds of talk therapy, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) and Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT).[3] SMART reports more than 1,500 meetings in the United States and more than 2,500 groups in over 23 countries.[3]
SMART is built around four points:[3]
- Build and keep motivation.
- Cope with urges and cravings.
- Manage thoughts, feelings, and behaviors.
- Live a balanced life.
There are no steps and no sponsors. Meetings are led by a trained facilitator and tend to work through a problem someone in the room is facing. SMART also says people choose their own goals, which is one reason it appeals to people who are not sure about lifelong abstinence.[3]
What about LifeRing and Women for Sobriety?
LifeRing describes its approach with three words, sobriety, secularity, and self-help. Meetings do not include prayer, and each person works out their own recovery plan. LifeRing asks for abstinence.[4]
Women for Sobriety is a program for women. Its “New Life” program is organized around 13 Acceptance Statements that focus on self-worth, responsibility, and changing negative thinking.[5]
Both are smaller than AA or SMART, so in-person meetings can be hard to find outside cities. Online meetings help fill that gap.
Does one group work better than the others?
Very little research compares peer groups to each other. The one long-term study that has done it did not find a clear winner.[8]
A 2020 Cochrane review looked at 27 studies with 10,565 people. It found that structured programs that help people get involved in AA did better than other common treatments, such as CBT, on keeping people continuously sober. In the two highest-quality studies, the rate of continuous abstinence at 12 months was about 21% higher with the AA approach.[7] The review covered alcohol, not other drugs.
A 2018 study followed 647 adults with a history of alcohol problems who went to WFS, LifeRing, SMART, or 12-step groups for a year.[8] People who were more involved in their group did better in every group. The study found no difference in how well the groups worked once people got involved. SMART and LifeRing members first looked like they did worse, but that gap went away once the researchers accounted for whether people had a goal of lifelong abstinence.[8] The authors said their results are tentative and suggested people are best served by having a range of groups to choose from.[8]
So the research supports AA for alcohol problems,[7] and one study suggests the other groups can work too.[8] In that 2018 study, how involved a person stayed mattered more than which group they picked.[8]
How do I pick the right group for me?
A few plain questions can narrow it down:
- Do you want a spiritual program or a secular one? AA and NA include a higher power of your own understanding. SMART and LifeRing do not include religion.[1][3][4]
- Do you want a sponsor? AA and NA use sponsors. SMART uses facilitators and group problem-solving.
- Is your goal to stop completely? AA, NA, LifeRing, and WFS ask for abstinence. SMART lets you set your own goals.[3][4]
- What can you get to? A group with a meeting near you, or online at a time you can make, beats a better fit you will never attend.
You can also try more than one. Going to two or three different meetings in your first couple of weeks is a normal way to find a fit. If a meeting feels wrong, try a different meeting of the same group before you rule the whole group out. Meetings vary a lot from room to room.
How do I find a meeting near me?
Each group runs its own meeting finder:
- AA: aa.org has a “Find A.A. Near You” tool, and the free Meeting Guide app lists local and online meetings.[1]
- NA: na.org has a meeting search.[2]
- SMART Recovery: smartrecovery.org lists in-person and online meetings.[3]
- LifeRing: lifering.org lists meetings, including online ones.[4]
- Women for Sobriety: womenforsobriety.org lists meetings.[5]
If you also need treatment, not just a group, SAMHSA’s free National Helpline at 1-800-662-HELP (4357) gives referrals to treatment and support groups, 24 hours a day.[9] For more on that first call, see who to call first when you need addiction help. If you are curious how identity-based recovery fits next to 12-step work, I wrote about that in identity-based recovery vs 12-step.
What I tell people who ask
People sometimes treat this like they have to pick a team. They do not. Plenty of people go to AA and SMART in the same week. The groups are free, the meetings are not going anywhere, and nobody checks whether you went somewhere else last Tuesday. If one room does not work for you, try another one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between AA and SMART Recovery?
AA follows the 12 Steps, uses sponsors, and includes a higher power of your own understanding. SMART Recovery uses tools from behavioral therapy, has trained facilitators instead of sponsors, and has no steps or religious content.[1][3]
Is SMART Recovery as effective as AA?
A 2018 study of 647 adults found no difference in how well SMART, LifeRing, Women for Sobriety, and 12-step groups worked for people who stayed involved, once goals were taken into account. The authors called the results tentative.[8]
Does AA actually work?
A 2020 Cochrane review of 27 studies found that structured programs that help people get involved in AA led to higher rates of continuous abstinence from alcohol than other common treatments such as CBT.[7]
Are there recovery groups that are not religious?
Yes. SMART Recovery and LifeRing Secular Recovery do not include religion. AA and NA mention a higher power but leave it to each member to decide what that means.[1][3][4]
Do recovery groups cost money?
AA says there are no dues or fees for membership.[1] The other groups listed here also run free peer meetings. Some ask for voluntary donations to cover rent and supplies.
Can I go to more than one recovery group?
Yes. Nothing stops you from going to more than one, and some people do. In the 2018 study, some people went to more than one group and were asked to name their main one. People did better the more involved they were in their group.[8]
References
- Alcoholics Anonymous. What is A.A.? and Find A.A. Near You. AA Preamble: desire to stop drinking; no dues or fees.
- Narcotics Anonymous World Services. NA.org and meeting search.
- SMART Recovery. What Is SMART Recovery? Four-point program, CBT and REBT basis, history and meeting counts.
- LifeRing Secular Recovery. Welcome. Sobriety, secularity, self-help; online meetings.
- Women for Sobriety. Acceptance Statements. New Life Program.
- Alcoholics Anonymous General Service Office. Estimated Worldwide A.A. Individual and Group Membership (SMF-132).
- Kelly JF, Humphreys K, Ferri M. Alcoholics Anonymous and other 12-step programs for alcohol use disorder. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2020;3:CD012880.
- Zemore SE, Lui C, Mericle A, Hemberg J, Kaskutas LA. A longitudinal study of the comparative efficacy of Women for Sobriety, LifeRing, SMART Recovery, and 12-step groups for those with AUD. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment. 2018;88:18-26.
- Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). National Helpline.