Table of contents
People use sobriety and recovery as if they mean the same thing. Sometimes that is close enough. Sometimes it hides the reason a person who stopped using is still miserable, and still at risk.
I learned the difference the hard way.
When I was 20, I stopped using for a while. I cut off my old friends, stopped going to parties, and went to AA. But I was still selling drugs, and I wrote later that I had taken away my old pastimes without replacing them with anything.[1] One Friday night around 7:00, I went through the contacts in my phone three times. All I saw were people I used to use with, dealers, and AA people I did not really know. I sat on my bed and cried. I remember thinking, “If this is what sobriety looks like, you can keep it.”[1]
I started using again shortly after that.
So when I write about recovery and sobriety, I am not splitting hairs. For me, the gap between them was the gap between staying clean and going back.
Direct Answer
Sobriety means not using alcohol or drugs. Recovery is broader. SAMHSA defines it as “a process of change through which individuals improve their health and wellness, live a self-directed life, and strive to reach their full potential,” and lists four parts: health, home, purpose, and community.[2] Not using is part of the health piece. The other three are about building a life. In a national survey, 9.1% of U.S. adults said they had resolved a significant alcohol or drug problem, but only 46% of them described themselves as “in recovery.”[3] People in recovery often describe it as a new life and a process of reclaiming the self, not only as abstinence.[4] That is why rebuilding identity takes longer than stopping use: it means new people, new routines, and a new answer to who you are.
What does sobriety mean?
Sobriety is the simplest part to define. It means not drinking or using drugs. Some people use it more loosely. In some groups, being “sober” includes not using any mood-altering substance at all. In others, people on medications like buprenorphine count themselves as sober, and SAMHSA’s definition talks about abstaining from “non-prescribed medications,” not prescribed ones.[2] I’m not going to settle that argument here. For this page, sobriety means the substance use has stopped.
For a lot of people, stopping is the hardest thing they have ever done. It is also the starting line, not the whole thing.
What does recovery mean?
SAMHSA’s working definition came out of a 2010 meeting of people in recovery, behavioral health leaders, and SAMHSA staff, and was published in 2012. It names four dimensions that support a life in recovery:[2]
| Dimension | What SAMHSA means |
|---|---|
| Health | Managing the condition, including not using if you have an addiction, and making healthy choices |
| Home | A stable and safe place to live |
| Purpose | Meaningful daily activities, like a job, school, volunteering, caretaking, or creative work, plus the income to take part in society |
| Community | Relationships and social networks that offer support, friendship, love, and hope |
Look at what is on that list.
Only part of one row is about the drug.
The researcher Alexandre Laudet asked 289 people with resolved crack or heroin dependence what recovery meant to them. Most said it meant total abstinence. But they also described it as a “new life,” an ongoing process of growth and self-change, and “reclaiming the self.”[4] They were not choosing between the two. They saw abstinence as necessary and recovery as bigger.
Why can stopping use leave you lost?
Using is rarely only about the substance. It decides who you spend time with, what you do on a Friday night, how you make money, and how you think about yourself.
When the using stops, all of that is still there, or it is suddenly gone with nothing in its place. Either way, the person has a hole in the middle of the week.
That was my experience at 20. I took the drugs out but kept the dealing. I cut off my friends but did not make new ones. The AA people were not my friends, and I was not comfortable around them.[1] I had sobriety for a while, and almost nothing else.
Researchers have a model for this. The Social Identity Model of Recovery, published by David Best and colleagues in 2016, describes recovery as a change in which groups a person belongs to. A using identity is held up by a using group. As a person joins groups that value recovery and starts to see themselves as one of them, the old identity matters less and the risk of going back drops.[5]
I had left the old group, but I had not joined a new one.
How is identity rebuilt, and how long does it take?
Gradually.
There is no single moment where a person becomes someone new.
NIDA describes addiction as a chronic condition and says relapse rates, about 40% to 60%, are similar to rates for other chronic illnesses like high blood pressure and asthma.[6] A person may stop and start more than once while the new life is still forming.
The Laudet study followed people over three yearly interviews, and they kept describing recovery as ongoing, not finished.[4] In the Kelly survey, more than half of the people who resolved a problem used some kind of help, most often mutual-help groups like AA or NA, then treatment, then newer recovery supports like recovery community centers.[3]
Years later, it went differently for me. After my release, I went to a lot of meetings to see where I fit. On my second day out, I asked a man named Ted to be my sponsor. He had been a teacher of mine in high school. On Saturday nights I played poker with him and some of the other guys. On Sunday mornings we worked out of the Big Book.[1]
I found my fellowship in NA in Kenosha. There were people my age there, people I could picture being friends with outside of meetings.[1] I wrote it plainly in my memoir: I wanted to be clean and needed people to show me how to do that. I knew how to get high.[1]
None of that was dramatic. It was a schedule, a few people, and a reason to show up.
What daily habits help build a recovery identity?
These are not rules, and they are not a program. They are the kinds of things the research keeps pointing back to. Each one adds a little to one of SAMHSA’s four dimensions.[2]
- Fill the empty hours on purpose. The time you used to spend using does not disappear. Put something specific in it, like a meeting, a gym time, a class, or a standing call.
- Join one group where recovery is normal. A meeting, a recovery community center, a faith group, or a sober sports league. The SIMOR model says belonging is part of the change, not a side benefit.[5]
- Keep one standing appointment with a person. My Saturday poker game and Sunday Big Book meeting with Ted were two of these.[1] Small, ordinary actions like showing up early to work, returning a call, or paying a bill on time also start to give you evidence of who you are now.
- Say it out loud to someone who knew the old you. I once told my dad, “I’m not the same man I was.”[1] Saying it did not make it true. It did make me accountable to it.
None of these replaces treatment, medication, or clinical care when someone needs it. They sit alongside it.
Is someone who stopped using but is still struggling “doing it wrong”?
No. They may just be early.
A lot of people who stop using feel worse before they feel better. The old life is gone and the new one has not filled in yet. That is the stretch where I went back to using at 20, and it is the stretch where a lot of people need the most support.
So if you are in that stretch, the question to ask is not only “Am I still clean?” It is also “What did I add this week?”
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between sobriety and recovery?
Sobriety means not using alcohol or drugs. Recovery is the larger process of building a life around that. SAMHSA defines recovery as a process of change toward health and wellness, a self-directed life, and reaching your potential, with four dimensions: health, home, purpose, and community.[2]
Can you be sober and not in recovery?
Yes. A person can stop using without building new relationships, routines, or a new sense of who they are. In a national survey, only 46% of adults who had resolved a substance problem described themselves as “in recovery.”[3]
Do you have to be abstinent to be in recovery?
Most people in Laudet’s study of 289 people said yes, recovery meant total abstinence for them, but they also said it went well beyond abstinence.[4] SAMHSA’s definition includes abstaining from alcohol, illicit drugs, and non-prescribed medications for people with an addiction.[2]
How long does it take to rebuild your identity in recovery?
There is no set timeline. People in long-term studies keep describing recovery as an ongoing process of growth and self-change.[4] The Social Identity Model of Recovery describes it as a gradual shift toward groups that value recovery.[5]
What are some daily habits that support a recovery identity?
Fill the hours you used to spend using with something specific, join one group where recovery is normal, keep a standing appointment with a supportive person, and do small things each day that match who you want to be.
If you run recovery groups
If you work with people who are early in recovery and want to talk about identity-focused group work, you can book a call.
References
- Drasen A. A Vision of Hope. Memoir. Chapter 20, “Sobriety? What’s That?” (age 20: still dealing, old pastimes not replaced, Friday night phone scene, “If this is what sobriety looks like, you can keep it,” using again shortly after); Chapter 36, “Recovery” (meetings, Ted as sponsor on the second day out, Saturday poker, Sunday Big Book, NA in Kenosha, “I wanted to be clean and needed people to show me how to do that. I knew how to get high.”); “I’m not the same man I was.”
- Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. SAMHSA’s Working Definition of Recovery. Publication PEP12-RECDEF. 2012. Definition; four dimensions of health, home, purpose, and community.
- Kelly JF, Bergman B, Hoeppner BB, Vilsaint C, White WL. Prevalence and pathways of recovery from drug and alcohol problems in the United States population. Drug and Alcohol Dependence. 2017;181:162-169. 9.1% resolved a problem; 46% self-identify as in recovery; 53.9% used assisted pathways; mutual help 45.1%, treatment 27.6%, recovery support services 21.8%.
- Laudet AB. What does recovery mean to you? Lessons from the recovery experience for research and practice. Journal of Substance Abuse Treatment. 2007;33(3):243-256. 289 inner-city residents with resolved crack or heroin dependence, interviewed yearly three times; most defined recovery as total abstinence; recovery also experienced as a “new life,” growth, self-change, and reclaiming the self.
- Best D, Beckwith M, Haslam C, et al. Overcoming alcohol and other drug addiction as a process of social identity transition: the social identity model of recovery (SIMOR). Addiction Research & Theory. 2016;24(2):111-123.
- National Institute on Drug Abuse. Treatment and Recovery. Drugs, Brains, and Behavior: The Science of Addiction. Relapse rates of 40% to 60%, similar to hypertension and asthma.